CONCEPT AND IMPORTANCE OF PANCHANAMA

"CONCEPT AND IMPORTANCE OF PANCHANAMA"

Usually, every person had heard about this word "Panchanama", most of the times we have seen this in Bollywood as well as in Marathi Movies, also in Daily Soaps i.e. crime scene, investigating officer, photographer, dog squad, forensic peoples, witnesses, etc. 

But is it in reality...? 

Does there is any PANCHANAMA in real life exist/ carried out by police administration/ authority ? 

Whether it is admissible proof of document ?  

Does it carry any importance to conclude the case...? 

All these above unanswered questions will be answered herein below:

PANCHANAMA:-

It is true that the word Panchanama is not defined anywhere in law. The judges, lawyers including me often take a search for this word in legal books. Common person who is suffering under court trial, accused, victims and witnesses their family members, lawyers, judges are known and somehow aware for this word as it has significance value in court of law, which is used and preferred by not only criminal courts but also civil courts in day to day cases. 

How...?

You will come to know.. while reading this article...

The Courts relying on this document to check veracity and truthfulness of the action taken by the officers of state or officers of court. In criminal case it is used to support the substantive evidence and in civil cases it is used to show that the decree of the civil court has been executed by handing over possession as directed in the decree. 

Question No. 1

What is mean by Panchanama? or Interpretation of word Panchanama?

Answer:-

The word Panchanama consists of two words, panch and nama. In Sanskrit the word "Panch" means a "respectable person." and "Nama" means a written document.

Question No. 2

What is the importance of Panchanama..?

Answer:-

In criminal cases this panchanama has very important value. The panchanama accounts state two things which were found at particular place at particular time. In criminal law the panchanama has corroborative value. The Code of Criminal Law Procedure 1973, also does not define panchanama anywhere. But the same is incorporated in the section 100 of the code. This section 100 can be found in chapter VII which titles Process To Compel The Production Of Things. In this chapter the power to carryout search of particular places is given to officers as laid down in sections 93, 95, 97 and 98 of the code. The provision of panchanama is made to convince court that officer have in fact carried out such search or made such seizure. 

Question No. 3

What are the contents of Panchanama...? 

Answer:-   

The procedure for preparing panchanama is not stated in any act. But a guidelines can be taken from section 100 subsection 4 and subsection 5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. It is to be also noted that the panchas are to be two or more independent and respectable persons. In the case where there is no eye witness to the offence and the case is totally based on circumstantial evidence then such panchanama carries immense value. The panch witness can also refresh his memories during the court of giving evidence as per section 159 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

In Panchanama the following things can be said to be important to be incorporated.

• Name and Place of Police Station.       
• Name and rank of officer commencing panchanama,
• Name, age and address of panchas,
• Details of particular place or persons.
• Details list of articles found in that place or from the person which are incriminating,
• Record of time when it was commenced and when it ended.
• Signatures of that officer and both of panchas.

It is also important that after preparation of panchanama the panchas  should read its contents. If the panch is illiterate then such panchanama should be read over to him and there should be endorsement that the contents of the panchanama were read over to them. In case where at time of making panchanama there was no source of light then it should be mentioned as to how the source of light was managed to prepare panchanama.

Question No. 4

WHAT ARE THE KINDS OF PANCHANAMA...? 

Answer:

There are many kinds of panchanamas, following are the panchanamas which are found normally in about every criminal cases. There can also be Panchanama other than the following list. 

1. SPOT PANCHANAMA:

This panchanama is generally drawn by Investigating Officer when he visits the informant or the person who has knowledge about place of crime. When such informant or such person shows the Investigating officer place of crime then in presence of two panchas the Investigating Officer draws spot panchanama. In this panchanama there are details of what where the position of scene of crime after the crime. 

For example 

If there is allegation of theft then generally in such panchanama it is found that the articles on the place of crime were scattered and cupboard or safe was broke open. So also in accident cases the tyre markes are often mentioned in this panchanama which shows that accused was driving his vehicle in speed or he tried to avoid accident. This panchanama corroborates the fact that incident had taken place. 

2. MEMORANDUM PANCHANAMA:

Generally any statement before police by accused while he is in police custody, cannot be taken on record and has no meaning in eyes of law. As per section 25 and 26 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 such statement has no value. But the exception to this section are made in the section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 which states that if in consequence of the information received by accused there is discovery then such fact could be proved in court. The statement made by accused in police custody is recorded before panchas and panchanama is drawn. Such Panchanama is called memorandum panchanama. If there is statement made by accused in police custody admitting the guilt and and further giving information about such things of which he only has knowledge and such things is found in that particular place then such discovery is relevant. 

For example 

In Murder case the accused in police custody can reveal as to where he had hidden the weapon of offence and in consequences of such information that weapon is found in that particular place, then such fact can be proved in court even if the statement is given in police custody. In memorandum panchanama it is always stated that accused admits the guilt and reveals the information about the articles. Though such incriminating statement is there in memorandum panchanama and punch witness makes such statement of accused before court but that has to be excluded from evidence.

3. SEIZURE PANCHANAMA:-

Whenever the investing officer founds any articles which he think that are necessary for proper investigation then such officers seized those articles from that place or person. While making such seizure he draws panchanama which is often called seizure panchanama. In one case there could be more than one seizure panchanama. The Seizure of article can be form informant, accused or any third person, depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case.

4. INQUEST PANCHANAMA:-

When any person dies due to the result of crime or under suspicious circumstances then the investigating officer has to draw inquest panchanama as per section 174 of criminal procedure code, 1973. In this panchanama the details of how the dead body is lying and descriptions such as of any mark of injuries found on a person of deceased, apparent cause of death or by what weapon, instrument such mark appear to have been inflicted are to be mentioned. 

This Panchanama helps to find out whether at the first sight of dead body it can be gather that cause of death is unnatural. After this cause of death and detailed description over body is mention in the Inquest Panchanama it is signed by the investing police officer and by the witnesses. If no foul play is suspected , the dead body is handed over to relatives for burial. In cases of suspected foul play or doubt the body is sent for postmortem examination to the nearest authorized government doctor or hospital, together with a requisition and copy of inquest. The report is also forwarded to the magistrate.

5. ARREST PANCHANAMA:-

Whenever the police officer carry out arrest of any person then such panchanama  is drawn. In this panchanama the physical appearance, identification marks and articles found on arrested person is mentioned. 

6. OTHER PANCHANAMA:-

The Panchanama can also be found in the case of Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and cases under Essential Commodities Act. In Prevention of Food Adulteration Act for safety and to give authenticity to their actions, the Food Inspectors prepared panchanama in presences of two panchas of all the action taken by them. This has two advantages, first it corroborates the fact that on the particular day such visit infact made by Food Inspector in that particular place and other is that it shows, the food inspector had followed proper procedure as prescribed in the Prevention Of Food Adulteration Rules. One can also found importance of Panchanama in Forest Offences. In Offences under Forest Act the Confession made by accused before Forest Officer is not hit by Section 25 of Indian Evidence Act. Such Confession stands in court of Law. Forest Officer records such confession before two panchas. This gives more reliability to such confession. Panchanamas are also done of test identification of accused or for identifying property involved in crime. Specimen handwriting's, Specimen signatures, sample of blood are also taken in presence of panchas by drawing panchnamas. In anti-corruption cases pre-trap panchanama and post- trap panchanama are common. In accident cases the panchanama about the condition of vehicles involved, its travel route, driver and conductor details, signal rules, injury, damage to vehicle etc. details are given special importance.                  

EVIDENTRY VALUE OF PANCHANAMA:-

The Panchanama is merely a record of what a panch sees and the only use of which it can properly be put is that when the panch goes into the witness box and swears as to what he saw, the panchanama can be used as a contemporary record to refresh his memory.               

The primary intention behind the panchanama is to guard against possible tricks and unfair dealings on the part of the officers entrusted with the execution of the search with or without warrant and also to ensure that anything incriminating which may be said to have been found in the premises search was really found there and was not introduced or planted by the officers of the search party. The legislative intent was to control and to check these malpractices of the officers, by making the presence of independent and respectable persons compulsory for search of place and seizure of article. The Panchanama can be used as a corroborative piece of evidence. In absence of any substantive piece of evidence only relying upon panchanama on record there can not be conviction. 

IMPORTANT CASE LAWS:-

1. In case of Vishnu Krishna Belurkar versus The State of Maharashtra, (1974) 76BOMLR627, the question whether the panchanama are hit by the provisions of section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The question was referred to Hon'ble Full Bench of High Court of Bombay. In para 8, the Hon'ble Full Bench has observed that

           " In our view, the fact that panchanama is written out by the police officer or the police scribe as dictated to him by the panchas would not make any difference, for that would merely be a made in which the panchanama id recorded. Of course, if a panchanama does incoporate a statement which amounts to a statement intended as a narration to a police officer during his investigation, it would fall withhin Section 162 and will have to be excluded but that is the duty which the court must perform every time a panchanama, is tendered in evidence."

2. In case of Yakub Abdul Razak Memon Versus State of Maharashtra ,  decided by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of 21st March 2013, one of the ground challenging conviction was that the recoveries which were made was not made in proper procedure and seizure panchanama were not in accordance with the procedure as laid down in Section 27 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 218 have observed that,

           "Panchanama is a document having legal bearings which records evidence and findings that an officer makes at the scene of an offence / crime. However, it is not only the recordings of the scene of crime but also of anywhere else which may be related to the crime/offence and from where incriminating evidence is likely to be collected. The document so prepared needs to be signed by the investigating officer who prepares the same and at least  by two independent and impartial witnesses called "Panchas" as also by the concerned party. The witnesses are required to be not only impartial but also 'respectable'. Respectable would mean a person who is not dis-reputed. One should also check if the witnesses are in their sense at the time of panchanama proceedings. Only majors are to be taken as a witnesses as minors witness may not withstand  the legal scrutiny."

Further in para 224 the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that

         " on any deviation from the procedure, the entire panchanama cannot be discarded and the proceedings are not vitiated. If any deviation from the procedure  occurs due to a practical impossibility then that should be recorded by the I.O. in his file so as to enable him to answer during the time of his examination as a witness in the court of law. Where there is a no availability of witness, the I.O. will conduct a search and seize the articles without panchas and draw a report of the entire such proceedings which is called a "Special Report". 

From the above two authorities it can be seen that the Hon'ble Court of Bombay and the Hon'ble Supreme Court had given in from of observations guidelines as to how the panchanamas should be and who should act as panchas.



Conclusion:-

So I can conclude this is very informative article and based on two important authorities as below:

• "PANCHANAMA" is a documentary evidence its contents can be brought on record by Primary Evidence.

• It's probative value can be inquired in the court of law by testimony of concern witnesses or Investigation Officer, who has investigated the case or proceed over the inquiry.

• It can also be use to refresh the memory during the proceedings.

• Duly proved 'Panchanama' establish genuineness of Investigation or Inquiry Procedure.

• Genuine PANCHANAMA are strong corroborative evidence to prove prosecution case. 

This is for information and for Knowledge:


www.advocatejjlegalawareness.blogspot.in